Dealer miss diagnose
Good evening all
I took my 05 2500 to the Dodge shop today for some clatering coming from the front end.... The Mech said it was the ideler pulley. I got a replacement from the auto parts store couse we all know the delear charges to much.
My dalema is it did not fix the problum. With the belt off I found the very top pully had some play in it. I know this to be the prob. How do I finde anouther one and how do I educate the dealer mec.
I took my 05 2500 to the Dodge shop today for some clatering coming from the front end.... The Mech said it was the ideler pulley. I got a replacement from the auto parts store couse we all know the delear charges to much.
My dalema is it did not fix the problum. With the belt off I found the very top pully had some play in it. I know this to be the prob. How do I finde anouther one and how do I educate the dealer mec.
Cummins Guru


Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,191
Likes: 65
From: Sunny Southern California Land of Fruits and Nuts
Number 3 is idler pulley, which one did you replace?
1 - Generator Pulley
2 - Water Pump Pulley
3 - Idler Pulley
4 - Power Steering Pump Pulley
5 - Radiator Fan Pulley
6 - Crankshaft Pulley
7 - Automatic Tensioner
1 - Generator Pulley
2 - Water Pump Pulley
3 - Idler Pulley
4 - Power Steering Pump Pulley
5 - Radiator Fan Pulley
6 - Crankshaft Pulley
7 - Automatic Tensioner
Your nit going to re-educate their guys. Most dealer mechanics simply take a symptom, look at a chart and do what the chart says. Especially when it come to a diesel vehicle. Occasionally you'll find one that really knows his stuff, but those guys are getting shafted by their employers and having to find other work. it's a tragedy. It's all about getting max profit.
Your nit going to re-educate their guys. Most dealer mechanics simply take a symptom, look at a chart and do what the chart says. Especially when it come to a diesel vehicle. Occasionally you'll find one that really knows his stuff, but those guys are getting shafted by their employers and having to find other work. it's a tragedy. It's all about getting max profit.
Trending Topics
Registered User

Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,252
Likes: 52
From: Whitehorse, cultural hub of the universe..
Good luck with it.
Well I have changed the Automatic Tensioner pully and the Idler Pully. With no luck. It still sounds like rocks in a can in the center of the radiator. Could it be the fan hub or any parts going with the pump????
Yes couse I replaced both the idler and tensioner pullys and still no fix. I worked with RR reps in Japan for the KC130 prupoltion systems. Any help would be greatfull.
Yes, the sound can be the fan clutch. With a cold engine, engage the dis-engage the AC and see if the sound changes.
You could also do a short run with the belt off and see if the noise goes away. Anything to isolate the issue will help.
I am in a different division (industrial) but I do try to help.
Yes, the sound can be the fan clutch. With a cold engine, engage the dis-engage the AC and see if the sound changes.
You could also do a short run with the belt off and see if the noise goes away. Anything to isolate the issue will help.
Yes, the sound can be the fan clutch. With a cold engine, engage the dis-engage the AC and see if the sound changes.
You could also do a short run with the belt off and see if the noise goes away. Anything to isolate the issue will help.
Cummins Guru


Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,191
Likes: 65
From: Sunny Southern California Land of Fruits and Nuts
Fan hub bearing is making the noise, I have changed a few over the years so stop chasing your tail around.. Remove fan clutch and shroud. Four bolts and the fan hub and bracket will come off. Bearing needs to be pressed out and in after removing center bolt.
Here is a link to previous thread https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/...ng-t90506.html
Remove pulley #4 and then remove bracket with bearing. 25+ years Dodge experience, not bragging just fact.
Here is a link to previous thread https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/...ng-t90506.html
Remove pulley #4 and then remove bracket with bearing. 25+ years Dodge experience, not bragging just fact.
Cummins Guru


Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,191
Likes: 65
From: Sunny Southern California Land of Fruits and Nuts
Found web site here with illustration. Part needed #4 $134.81
http://www.moparpartsamerica.com/par...ke=8&model=Ram 2500&year=2007&graphicID=TH03110&callout=7&catalog id=2&displayCatalogid=0
http://www.moparpartsamerica.com/par...ke=8&model=Ram 2500&year=2007&graphicID=TH03110&callout=7&catalog id=2&displayCatalogid=0
Fan hub bearing is making the noise, I have changed a few over the years so stop chasing your tail around.. Remove fan clutch and shroud. Four bolts and the fan hub and bracket will come off. Bearing needs to be pressed out and in after removing center bolt.
Here is a link to previous thread https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/...ng-t90506.html
Remove pulley #4 and then remove bracket with bearing. 25+ years Dodge experience, not bragging just fact.
Here is a link to previous thread https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/...ng-t90506.html
Remove pulley #4 and then remove bracket with bearing. 25+ years Dodge experience, not bragging just fact.


