Mechanical or Electrical gauges.....
Mechanical or Electrical gauges.....
Gentleman,
I am looking to get a fuel pressure gauge and a Transmission temp gauge. Do I want Mechanical or Electrical?
Thanks in advance,
David
I am looking to get a fuel pressure gauge and a Transmission temp gauge. Do I want Mechanical or Electrical?
Thanks in advance,
David
Mechanical. For the fuel pressure you mount the isolater (fuel runs to this) on the firewall then you run a small oil pressure line into the cab. You fill the line with silcone spray so thers no fuel in the drivers compartment. Mechanical are much more accurate. For the trans you have to have an electrical wire.
Like Dave said, mechanical gauges have a 270* sweep; whereas, electricals are limited to only a 90* sweep.
I much prefer mechanical gauges; the factory gauges are electrical and no one really trusts them; why should they trust another electrical gauge any more than the factory ones??
I much prefer mechanical gauges; the factory gauges are electrical and no one really trusts them; why should they trust another electrical gauge any more than the factory ones??
Like Dave said, mechanical gauges have a 270* sweep; whereas, electricals are limited to only a 90* sweep.
I much prefer mechanical gauges; the factory gauges are electrical and no one really trusts them; why should they trust another electrical gauge any more than the factory ones??
I much prefer mechanical gauges; the factory gauges are electrical and no one really trusts them; why should they trust another electrical gauge any more than the factory ones??
Trending Topics
Part of the attraction to first gens in my opinion is the fact that they are almost 100% mechanical in operation. When you start throwing electrical components on them it kind of ruins the "old school" factor. Just my 2 cents
I'd just run mech. I don't really care if diesel is in a tube in the cab to be honest. Not a big deal if it leaks imo, it's not volatile like gasoline is. I'd never run gas into the cab.
You can get most of the better name electric gauges with a 270* full sweep or in a traditional 90* with an air core movement.
The 270* full sweep use a microprocessor and a stepper motor to drive the pointer instead of a traditional air core movement which drives the 90* style.
http://www.autometer.com/cat_gaugeop.aspx?sid=61
I like mechanical temperature gauges because you can monitor heat soak temperatures that occur after the engine is shut down however they are a pain to install with the attached sensing bulb,
I also like electric gauges because you can monitor more that one heat source with additional senders and a switch.
I once had to replace a mechanical temperature gauge on a transit coach; the coiled probe was 50’ long.
Also I haven’t seen these for Autometers but I used to only run Stuart Warners and they used to have a small pointer that clipped over the bezel and you could set them at your target points on the dial, this was easy to see at a glance as the pointer approached the set point.
In racecars they will orient the gauge with the target number at 12:00 o clock position, easier to read when the pointer is straight up.
Jim
The 270* full sweep use a microprocessor and a stepper motor to drive the pointer instead of a traditional air core movement which drives the 90* style.
http://www.autometer.com/cat_gaugeop.aspx?sid=61
I like mechanical temperature gauges because you can monitor heat soak temperatures that occur after the engine is shut down however they are a pain to install with the attached sensing bulb,
I also like electric gauges because you can monitor more that one heat source with additional senders and a switch.
I once had to replace a mechanical temperature gauge on a transit coach; the coiled probe was 50’ long.
Also I haven’t seen these for Autometers but I used to only run Stuart Warners and they used to have a small pointer that clipped over the bezel and you could set them at your target points on the dial, this was easy to see at a glance as the pointer approached the set point.
In racecars they will orient the gauge with the target number at 12:00 o clock position, easier to read when the pointer is straight up.
Jim
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
genros
3rd Gen High Performance and Accessories (5.9L Only)
5
Apr 6, 2006 10:21 PM
wap
3rd Gen High Performance and Accessories (5.9L Only)
5
Dec 5, 2005 09:02 AM
Dojman
Performance and Accessories 2nd gen only
3
Mar 6, 2004 12:52 PM
Diesel Dave
Performance and Accessories 2nd gen only
4
Jan 3, 2003 03:37 PM
Commatoze
Performance and Accessories 2nd gen only
23
Nov 22, 2002 02:10 PM








