Building a dead reliable 2004.5-2007 5.9L Common Rail.
#16
Chapter President
I tested industrial engines back in the late 90's with ceramic coatings. For all the cost, there was no change in performance or reliability. And we measured peak firing pressures in the engine with transducers to see if there was any change in combustion pressures or temperatures.. Notta. Sorry, I don't think its worth the cost IMHO..
#17
Registered User
Thread Starter
Excellent points all around, gents.
Big Swole scares me! He's scattered a few 04.5+ engines in a variety of ways..
I agree with your "fix the root cause" point. The 03-04 piston & bowl design is superior & that addresses the root cause.
Its tough to say if the ceramic coating helps or not. Its like a rock that keeps tigers away. Just because there are no tigers here, doesn't mean its because of that special rock. Big Swole had his pistons coated, and in the end, most of that coating wound up in the exhaust. Granted, he's a bad example of reliability and longevity, but the fact remains, ceramic coating is a bandaid at best. Gotta fix the root cause, which is poor programming and poor piston/injector design.
Big Swole scares me! He's scattered a few 04.5+ engines in a variety of ways..
I agree with your "fix the root cause" point. The 03-04 piston & bowl design is superior & that addresses the root cause.
#21
Registered User
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Edmonton, AB
Posts: 116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Besides monotherms I don't think there is much for piston alternatives( besides fly cuts for larger cams). The aftermarket cant really do much to the 04.5 piston to keep it from melting. The design is just bad.
#22
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Airdrie, AB
Posts: 954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The best choice if you are going aluminum is the QSB marine pistons, they are double heat treated and are 30% stronger then OTR pistons, and they have the keystone ring land. The best choice period is the monotherm.
#23
The Guru
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Airdrie Canada
Posts: 6,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
We seen actual decrease in flow with bigger camshafts at the lower lifts. Once I find the graphs, or the thread I'm post them. For 5.9/6.7 CR crowd, the colt stage 3/4 is enough.
Forgot about the forged pistons not having the keystone lands for the top ring. The metal piston cooler jets has been discontinued, and all you can buy is the plastic jet. Still trying to source QSB jets, hopefully they are metal.
QSB pistons are 3-4 week custom order from the factory. Just ordered mine on Friday.
#24
The Guru
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Airdrie Canada
Posts: 6,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just throwing this out, heard a few issues with the colt stage 2 cam's. The cam has a more aggressive ramp rate than stock or stage 3 (Similar lift but has more duration, which slows down tappet ramp rate). If your going to run a stage 2 cam, its a good idea to check for piston to valve clearance. You might have to adjust stuff.
I've only used stage 3 stuff.
I've only used stage 3 stuff.
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Alberta
Posts: 337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Buddies 06 has gone down. So be doing research on engine parts, etc. Called about the monotherms, less than a month ago there was no pistons avaiable. Spoke with Mahle, there were building some, but dont be in any type of a hurry to get them.
#26
Registered User
Well you pretty much have the dead reliable down, not a lot to make it better. A cam isn't a bad idea, but I doubt it would effect your reliability.
Good, clean oil, reasonable coolant temps, reasonable EGT's and not letting the cylinder pressure exceed the holding capacity of the HG/bolts(studs).
I presume your EGT's are a little lower than mine since you have twins.. but I can pull WOT up a 6% grade at 6K feet plus and be just on the edge of my EGT comfort level at 16K in 6th. Above that weight I need to downshift, but that's fine.
With the parts you have EGT's will be your downfall, and it sounds like that's not an issue.
But if you were to do a build and money wasn't a concern, on top of what you have now...
Coated QSB480 pistons
03-04 50hp Nozzles
Pushrods
Cam
Balanced bottom end
6.7 fuel system
BB Twins (GT3782/GT4202)
4.10's (less torque output from the motor for the same wheel tq)
Good, clean oil, reasonable coolant temps, reasonable EGT's and not letting the cylinder pressure exceed the holding capacity of the HG/bolts(studs).
I presume your EGT's are a little lower than mine since you have twins.. but I can pull WOT up a 6% grade at 6K feet plus and be just on the edge of my EGT comfort level at 16K in 6th. Above that weight I need to downshift, but that's fine.
With the parts you have EGT's will be your downfall, and it sounds like that's not an issue.
But if you were to do a build and money wasn't a concern, on top of what you have now...
Coated QSB480 pistons
03-04 50hp Nozzles
Pushrods
Cam
Balanced bottom end
6.7 fuel system
BB Twins (GT3782/GT4202)
4.10's (less torque output from the motor for the same wheel tq)
#27
The Guru
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Airdrie Canada
Posts: 6,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm building a 06 CTD engine right now with 480 marines, brand new head, oringed, colt stage 3 cam, available with 12V or CR rods, 425 ARP's head/mains. Its available if you want. Everything is brand new included the head, 480 pistons, oil pump, and so on. I just got this stuff laying around. I was planning on throwing on a steed manifold T-4 and run my S366. My plans was to use it for an older chevy project that I was dreaming.
#28
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Airdrie, AB
Posts: 954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just wanted to mention, we have a customer that has decided he wants the ultimate street engine. So we will be building just what I was talking about here in the next month or so:
-R&R's
-Monotherms
-Ported & Milled head with Hellmann intake
-Balanced
-Steed exhaust manifold
-Decent sized twins
Looking for a reliable 800hp, with the ability to go over 1000hp.
I will try and post up some "spy" pics as we build it.
-R&R's
-Monotherms
-Ported & Milled head with Hellmann intake
-Balanced
-Steed exhaust manifold
-Decent sized twins
Looking for a reliable 800hp, with the ability to go over 1000hp.
I will try and post up some "spy" pics as we build it.
#29
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Airdrie, AB
Posts: 954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mahle only builds monotherm's once a year according to Eric at Mahle, they are doing the production run right now. We have a couple sets on order.
#30
The Guru
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Airdrie Canada
Posts: 6,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just wanted to mention, we have a customer that has decided he wants the ultimate street engine. So we will be building just what I was talking about here in the next month or so:
-R&R's
-Monotherms
-Ported & Milled head with Hellmann intake
-Balanced
-Steed exhaust manifold
-Decent sized twins
Looking for a reliable 800hp, with the ability to go over 1000hp.
I will try and post up some "spy" pics as we build it.
-R&R's
-Monotherms
-Ported & Milled head with Hellmann intake
-Balanced
-Steed exhaust manifold
-Decent sized twins
Looking for a reliable 800hp, with the ability to go over 1000hp.
I will try and post up some "spy" pics as we build it.