Sooted Tail Pipe...2 Different Opinions
Sooted Tail Pipe...2 Different Opinions
I've read on these forums that soot in the tailpipe usually indicates a cracked DPF. Having noticed soot in my trucks tailpipe I thought I'd call two different dealerships in order to get opinions from their service personnel. The answers I received were totally contrary and certainly don't engender much faith in the abilities of their respective service departments. Examples below:
Dealership #1: Service person tells me he is certain the soot is being caused by a leaky injector since he has seen this happen before.
Dealership #2: Service person says soot is NOT being caused by a leaky injector since I'm not seeing any CEL's.
I'm wondering if both these guys are wrong. How can a leaky injector throw a CEL? Can the computer actually detect this? Thanks for your answers...
(PS..Does the DPF trap 100% of the soot or is a little soot in the tailpipe normal, especially if it takes a long time to show up?)
Dealership #1: Service person tells me he is certain the soot is being caused by a leaky injector since he has seen this happen before.
Dealership #2: Service person says soot is NOT being caused by a leaky injector since I'm not seeing any CEL's.
I'm wondering if both these guys are wrong. How can a leaky injector throw a CEL? Can the computer actually detect this? Thanks for your answers...
(PS..Does the DPF trap 100% of the soot or is a little soot in the tailpipe normal, especially if it takes a long time to show up?)
Cummins Guru


Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,191
Likes: 65
From: Sunny Southern California Land of Fruits and Nuts
I've read on these forums that soot in the tailpipe usually indicates a cracked DPF. Having noticed soot in my trucks tailpipe I thought I'd call two different dealerships in order to get opinions from their service personnel. The answers I received were totally contrary and certainly don't engender much faith in the abilities of their respective service departments. Examples below:
Dealership #1: Service person tells me he is certain the soot is being caused by a leaky injector since he has seen this happen before.
Dealership #2: Service person says soot is NOT being caused by a leaky injector since I'm not seeing any CEL's.
I'm wondering if both these guys are wrong. How can a leaky injector throw a CEL? Can the computer actually detect this? Thanks for your answers...
(PS..Does the DPF trap 100% of the soot or is a little soot in the tailpipe normal, especially if it takes a long time to show up?)
Dealership #1: Service person tells me he is certain the soot is being caused by a leaky injector since he has seen this happen before.
Dealership #2: Service person says soot is NOT being caused by a leaky injector since I'm not seeing any CEL's.
I'm wondering if both these guys are wrong. How can a leaky injector throw a CEL? Can the computer actually detect this? Thanks for your answers...
(PS..Does the DPF trap 100% of the soot or is a little soot in the tailpipe normal, especially if it takes a long time to show up?)
Will running with a cracked DPF cause any harm to the engine or other components? I don't have to worry about emissions testing, have only about 600 miles left on warranty but am not near a dealership. I don't mind a little soot in the tailpipe if that's the only issue...
Administrator / Severe Concussion Aficionado
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 5,491
Likes: 15
From: Home: Kaplan, LA - Pipelining In: Pecos, Tx
Will running with a cracked DPF cause any harm to the engine or other components? I don't have to worry about emissions testing, have only about 600 miles left on warranty but am not near a dealership. I don't mind a little soot in the tailpipe if that's the only issue...
X2 ^^^ I would not want to get it into limp mode and then you're forced to go unplanned... You have a warantee, so get it fixed for sure or at least diagnosed and fixe what you can on their $.
Cummins Guru


Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 4,191
Likes: 65
From: Sunny Southern California Land of Fruits and Nuts
Will running with a cracked DPF cause any harm to the engine or other components? I don't have to worry about emissions testing, have only about 600 miles left on warranty but am not near a dealership. I don't mind a little soot in the tailpipe if that's the only issue...
I appreciate the replies. I received some info on another forum from a guy who checked with 2 dealerships employing several diesel techs. Their answer was that a little soot in the tailpipe may be considered normal as long as there is no black smoke and the soot had taken a long time to accumulate. I'm hoping this answer is correct because I'm not going to be in a position to have it looked at under warranty (my bad
). And yes, it did take a long time to notice the soot (probably over a period of a year or more).
). And yes, it did take a long time to notice the soot (probably over a period of a year or more).
Trending Topics
I would have it repaired ASAP, DPF is 2500 dollars plus other emissions parts that may need replacing. If the DPF is plugged it will derate power and could cause other engine damage. GET IT FIXED! Turbo cost $3500 O2 sensors, EGR valve cooler are also pricey emission parts that you don't want to pay for.

Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
jhenson
3rd Gen Engine and Drivetrain -> 2003-2007
3
Sep 8, 2012 10:37 PM
Fisherguy
3rd Gen High Performance and Accessories (5.9L Only)
29
Aug 6, 2009 12:45 PM
Dave88LX
Performance and Accessories 2nd gen only
4
Dec 8, 2006 02:53 PM




