Volunteer Fire Department out of control?
#16
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Minneapolis, MN
Posts: 172
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There are a number of rural areas in northern Minnesota that have these membership funded fire departments.
There was a case recently where a house burned because the owner didn't pay the dues. I think they did respond to make sure there wasn't a life threatening issue. I believe the county is thinking about a tax supported department after this incident.
If they go out and fight every fire, nobody would pay the dues. I wonder what happens if I get in an car accident in their area? I don't live there so I can't have paid dues in advance.
Brian Elfert
There was a case recently where a house burned because the owner didn't pay the dues. I think they did respond to make sure there wasn't a life threatening issue. I believe the county is thinking about a tax supported department after this incident.
If they go out and fight every fire, nobody would pay the dues. I wonder what happens if I get in an car accident in their area? I don't live there so I can't have paid dues in advance.
Brian Elfert
#17
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Tulsa OK
Posts: 694
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Gotlift01
So let me get this straight, you have to PAY to have your home protected??? What a bunch of crap. I'm sorry, but that's the fire departments responsibility to protect local citizens is it not?
So is it the same with the police department, if you don't pay your crap dues, they will sit on the curb drinking lemonade eating ice cream while you're being robbed or murdered?
That is freaking retarded, someone needs to get their butts kicked for that!! That makes me MAD!!
~Nick
So is it the same with the police department, if you don't pay your crap dues, they will sit on the curb drinking lemonade eating ice cream while you're being robbed or murdered?
That is freaking retarded, someone needs to get their butts kicked for that!! That makes me MAD!!
~Nick
#18
Originally Posted by Shovelhead
We recently had an incident with two local VFDs brawling at a fire scene.
What the news isn't saying is that the rookie driving VFD #2's truck arrived on the scene and parked his truck ON TOP on VFD #1's hose already streched out into the fire scene where #1's Fire Fighters were engaging the fire.
http://www.wjla.com/news/stories/0206/303643.html
What the news isn't saying is that the rookie driving VFD #2's truck arrived on the scene and parked his truck ON TOP on VFD #1's hose already streched out into the fire scene where #1's Fire Fighters were engaging the fire.
http://www.wjla.com/news/stories/0206/303643.html
What a joke, I hear these guys were shutting off each others air and all.
#19
Registered User
Originally Posted by Hoss
It's unfortunate. Neighbors used to help each other out...firemen or not. I'm sorry, but I couldn't just sit there and watch a man's house burn down without trying to help...ESPECIALLY if I had the equipment right in front of me to put the fire out. That's not right.
I'm just pulling your leg. (leave the thong out of this! )
#20
Registered User
Originally Posted by P.J
You beat me to it, I was going to post this same incident.
What a joke, I hear these guys were shutting off each others air and all.
What a joke, I hear these guys were shutting off each others air and all.
I finally quit after getting yelled at because on a fire call I put a vehicle fire with my personal fire extingusher (in full bunker gear) and saved the vehicle. They wanted me to wait for back up so they could use the hose.
Silly me, I thought firemen were suppose to put out fires.
#21
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Corpus Christi, Tx.
Posts: 372
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
WAAAAY back in time when I was young and foolish, I was a VFD member and we looked forwards to getting an out-of-city-limits call because the county would reimburse the city's VFD a whopping $100 per call.. Hey, it was better than in-city calls where the dept got paid something like $7 per call..
K.
K.
#22
Administrator
This is actually quite a common practice, mostly in rural areas, called a 'subscription' based service. Most often, there is NO tax based financial support for the fire department, thus the membership/subscription fee. I don't know if that was the case for the fire department/town mentioned in the article or not, but I'd be willing to bet it was.
The last paragraph of the article states, "Rural Monett members have not been asked to choose between memberships and tax support, though they came out strongly against a proposed Aurora Rural Bi-County Fire Protection District, which was voted down in 2001." This leads me to believe they voted against a tax base funded fire department, choosing instead to remain with the subscription/membership type of arrangement.
A year or so ago, we did some training for a fire department that went back to the subscription arrangement after being tax base funded for 15 years. The town voters had kept cutting the FD budget until it got to the point that there was no money left for gas for the trucks, let alone any hope of needed safety gear or supplies. At least now with the subscription service, they have some safe equipment and gear to work with. They won't let ANYONE go without treatment for an injury, or refuse to attempt rescue from a burning building, but they won't attempt to extinguish a fire in someone's house who has refused to pay their subscription fee either if no one's life is in danger.
I don't know if I agree with the subscription policies or not, but the money has to come from somewhere or there won't BE a fire department. And if everyone didn't pay their fee with the idea that they'll pay if they NEED the FD, there wouldn't be any monies either. I guess it's like anything else, if you want a service, you have to pay for it or do without it.
As far as recovering the costs from a homeowners' insurance policy; the most any insurance company will pay for firefighting operations is $500, regardless of costs incurred by the FD.
Just my take on the whole thing.
chaikwa.
The last paragraph of the article states, "Rural Monett members have not been asked to choose between memberships and tax support, though they came out strongly against a proposed Aurora Rural Bi-County Fire Protection District, which was voted down in 2001." This leads me to believe they voted against a tax base funded fire department, choosing instead to remain with the subscription/membership type of arrangement.
A year or so ago, we did some training for a fire department that went back to the subscription arrangement after being tax base funded for 15 years. The town voters had kept cutting the FD budget until it got to the point that there was no money left for gas for the trucks, let alone any hope of needed safety gear or supplies. At least now with the subscription service, they have some safe equipment and gear to work with. They won't let ANYONE go without treatment for an injury, or refuse to attempt rescue from a burning building, but they won't attempt to extinguish a fire in someone's house who has refused to pay their subscription fee either if no one's life is in danger.
I don't know if I agree with the subscription policies or not, but the money has to come from somewhere or there won't BE a fire department. And if everyone didn't pay their fee with the idea that they'll pay if they NEED the FD, there wouldn't be any monies either. I guess it's like anything else, if you want a service, you have to pay for it or do without it.
As far as recovering the costs from a homeowners' insurance policy; the most any insurance company will pay for firefighting operations is $500, regardless of costs incurred by the FD.
Just my take on the whole thing.
chaikwa.
#24
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Corpus Christi, Tx.
Posts: 372
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Geico266
We were suppose to get gas money as firemen, but they stole that too. It was a mess.
I finally quit after getting yelled at because on a fire call I put a fire out a vehicle fire with my personal fire extingusher (in full bunker gear) and saved the vehicle. They wanted me to wait for back up so they could use the hose.
I finally quit after getting yelled at because on a fire call I put a fire out a vehicle fire with my personal fire extingusher (in full bunker gear) and saved the vehicle. They wanted me to wait for back up so they could use the hose.
I guess we had a pretty tame, proficient VFD considering the old chief just loved to work on old surplus junk ALL the time..
Long after I wasn't a VFD member, I put out a sizable gasoline fire in my neighbor's carport storage room with my ancient BC 30pounder .. The old chief heard about it and came by and insisted on picking it up from me. He had it hydro'ed and refilled at city expense... He said, "You saved the city lots of $$ by using this" .
K.
#25
Registered User
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Oldenburg, Indiana
Posts: 1,065
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Our fire dept. up here is funded by a tax district. Everybody pays the tax whether they live in town or in the country this has helped out alot. Before the tax district we had to frie chicken every other weekend just to pay for fuel and insurance
#26
Registered User
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Central Arkansas
Posts: 201
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok, here we go. I'm a member of a rural VFD. My better half is also Tres. of the dept. We get Act 833 money from the state every quarter. Our district voted years ago to add 1/10th of 1% on to their property taxes for fire TAXES. Don't know how fair it is cause some pay more, some pay less. WE have never stood by and let a house or property burn. Actually we put out the fire and ask questions later. We are automatic mutial aid for the city in this county, and automatic mutial aid for 4 other districts for tanker shuttle. We receive no personal compensention at all for our services. Like has already been said> THEY SHOULD BE ASHAMED
#28
Registered User
Can you see trying to explain this to you homeowners insurance adjuster?
"Did you call the FD?"...."yes I did.........they just stood there and watched my house burn to the ground"
Just the mental picture is amazing.....be driving down the street, seeing this place ablaze, with the FD standing there.
Still blows my mind, that they would let a persons whole lifes belongs go up in smoke, and not give a rats *** about it.
Geez........send the dude a bill or something in the mail. If he don't pay that, then go back and light his place on fire again.
.....only in America
"Did you call the FD?"...."yes I did.........they just stood there and watched my house burn to the ground"
Just the mental picture is amazing.....be driving down the street, seeing this place ablaze, with the FD standing there.
Still blows my mind, that they would let a persons whole lifes belongs go up in smoke, and not give a rats *** about it.
Geez........send the dude a bill or something in the mail. If he don't pay that, then go back and light his place on fire again.
.....only in America
#29
Registered User
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: The Eastern Shore
Posts: 576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm a volunteer fire fighter in a rural area. Our dept is funded from county state and federal funds. The only service that gets billed is if you are transported in the ambulance, there's a 350 fee, goes to your insurance policy, I believe. Most people around here will do anything to help someone in need. I think the # of volunteer fire fighters per capita is higher on the delmarva peninsula than anywhere else on earth.
#30
Originally Posted by Timberman
I think the # of volunteer fire fighters per capita is higher on the delmarva peninsula than anywhere else on earth.
My son had a pretty wicked dirt bike accident in November of 2003. The firemen and ambulance were the first responders and really knew their stuff. The immediately decided to call for the State Police medivac after checking out his level of injury.
The chopper took 11 minutes to put the skids on the ground at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore 74 miles away from our side yard.
Awesome, pure and simple.
Completely profession and compassioniate service all around.
I think they should build in set fees into our property taxes SPECIFICALLY for VFD's, not from general fund to be pillaged by the lawmakers,straight to the firehouses.