Best All-Terrain Tire For Mud.....?
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 312
Likes: 0
From: Gonzales Co., Texas (HOOK'EM & Gig'em!)
Best All-Terrain Tire For Mud.....?
My wife hates mud lugs humming;says I can go camping by myself if she has to hear "All That".........I need good traction in mud without the road noise.
Who makes best a-t type tire for slingin mud..? Also interested in very quiet
mt's. I know they've come a long way with computer tread designs & all.
Who makes best a-t type tire for slingin mud..? Also interested in very quiet
mt's. I know they've come a long way with computer tread designs & all.
Ive been really pleased with the performance of my Pro Comp Extreme A/T's. Not Xterrains or A/T's but Extreme A/T's. Mine have about 14k on em with probably 75-80% tread left. They are a very quiet tire but are very capable.
Nitto Terra Grappler A/T's are the only choice for me. I love them. I have 34,000 miles on my 295's and they are still at least half tread or better. They also have a 50,000 mile warranty, who else offers that? And they are super quiet.
ProComp XTA's do just fine in MUD. 
I have run BFG MT's, Goodyear MTR's, and Toyo MT's...and htese tires are darn close at low speeds...and one you light them up...they clear and grab fine.
I will NEVER go back. All of the other positives ov the XTA over a "true" MT is night and day. Quiet as OEM tires, GREAT dry, wet, and icy pavement manners/grip...
On edit...don't forget the 23/32 tread depth on some of the bigger sizes!
IIRC that would be 2x the depth of a Nitto or Toyo AT. LOL

I have run BFG MT's, Goodyear MTR's, and Toyo MT's...and htese tires are darn close at low speeds...and one you light them up...they clear and grab fine.
I will NEVER go back. All of the other positives ov the XTA over a "true" MT is night and day. Quiet as OEM tires, GREAT dry, wet, and icy pavement manners/grip...
On edit...don't forget the 23/32 tread depth on some of the bigger sizes!
IIRC that would be 2x the depth of a Nitto or Toyo AT. LOL
Trending Topics
ProComp XTA's do just fine in MUD. 
I have run BFG MT's, Goodyear MTR's, and Toyo MT's...and htese tires are darn close at low speeds...and one you light them up...they clear and grab fine.
I will NEVER go back. All of the other positives ov the XTA over a "true" MT is night and day. Quiet as OEM tires, GREAT dry, wet, and icy pavement manners/grip...
On edit...don't forget the 23/32 tread depth on some of the bigger sizes!
IIRC that would be 2x the depth of a Nitto or Toyo AT. LOL

I have run BFG MT's, Goodyear MTR's, and Toyo MT's...and htese tires are darn close at low speeds...and one you light them up...they clear and grab fine.
I will NEVER go back. All of the other positives ov the XTA over a "true" MT is night and day. Quiet as OEM tires, GREAT dry, wet, and icy pavement manners/grip...
On edit...don't forget the 23/32 tread depth on some of the bigger sizes!
IIRC that would be 2x the depth of a Nitto or Toyo AT. LOL
I am on my second set of Pro Comp Extreme ATs. I got 45k
from the first set and as you can see on my sig I have plenty of extra weight in the front bumper and winch. I go off road alot here in SOCAL but they really performed well in Colorado during elk season. The mud is like peanut butter. This is the only AT tire I have not had to put chains on to get to my hunting camp. Plus they are as quiet as the stock Michelin LTX road tires that were original equipment. My buddy has a long bed and runs the BFG ATs and gets similar results but he always gets stuck without the chains. They both are quiet tires but all things being equal I would go with the Pro Comp.
Chalk up another vote for Pro Comp XAT's. They are great on snow/ice and hold up real well on gravel roads. They perform a lot better in mud than I expected, not giving away much to a true mud tire. They also work better in sand than a mud tire, as the don't want to dig themselves a grave.
Pro comp XTA's will be my next set of shoes for my rig in 37/12.50/17. But I have been very happy with my BFG AT KO's also. (close to 40K miles on them at the moment, took them off my 04 hemi, and, and I still have atlest 65-70% tread left on them.
Thread Starter
Registered User
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 312
Likes: 0
From: Gonzales Co., Texas (HOOK'EM & Gig'em!)
I really like the Open Country M/T's. I had a '94 Ferd 4x4 with Kelly M/T's
(I think they were Safaris...?..Had a real open agressive tread like Buckshot
Mudders & Gumbo Mudders. I think they were among the loudest tires back then....She's been gun-shy since then.
Last edited by koogala; May 8, 2007 at 09:29 PM. Reason: omission


