Dodge Diesel - Diesel Truck Resource Forums

Dodge Diesel - Diesel Truck Resource Forums (https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/forums/)
-   General Diesel Discussion (https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/forums/general-diesel-discussion-92/)
-   -   What is the best year for the CUMMINS? (https://www.dieseltruckresource.com/forums/general-diesel-discussion-92/what-best-year-cummins-124077/)

nchapa 11-15-2006 11:38 AM

What is the best year for the CUMMINS?
 
What is the best year for the Cummins? for reliability, and for plain ole' hot rodding.

I have heard the 98.5 is the best and i have also heard any 12V is the best, what is you all's opinion. AND WHY?

JyRO 11-15-2006 04:19 PM

That there is a loaded question. You might as well forget it. You're going to walk away more confused than before you asked.

Most reliable - I'd take a 12 valve due to the P7100, and simple mechanical nature of the beast. 98 model for the quad cab, and 12 valve. 98.5 went to the 24 valve.

Most power - I'm sure you can pump out plenty o' power with a 12 valve, but it just makes sense that the more valves you have, the more air you can blow through the pump. So, take your pick of 24 valves, I guess.

The main problem with this question is that you can get more power than you need with basically any Cummins powered Ram, and plenty of reliability once you have just 1 or 2 small items tackled. If I were to narrow it down, I'd say the '92 models through the '07 (excluding the '07.5) were the best for reliability and hotrodding.

- JyRO

dodgezilla04 11-15-2006 04:23 PM

reliability can be sacrificed with too much hotrodding. as with anything.

the newer common rails are easier to build quick, cheap power with. just plug in a downloader or module, and easily 130 hp additional.


As far as reliable, depends on the trans you get and how much you abuse it.

Forrest Nearing 11-15-2006 06:33 PM


Originally Posted by JyRO (Post 1210778)
Most power - I'm sure you can pump out plenty o' power with a 12 valve, but it just makes sense that the more valves you have, the more air you can blow through the pump. So, take your pick of 24 valves, I guess.

a ported 12v head will outflow a 24v head, and you don't have to buy exotic valvetrain to turn 4000rpm... wait... I don't think a 24v will turn 4000rpm without a 12v injection pump ;)

inline6power 11-15-2006 07:38 PM


Originally Posted by Forrest Nearing (Post 1210961)
a ported 12v head will outflow a 24v head, and you don't have to buy exotic valvetrain to turn 4000rpm... wait... I don't think a 24v will turn 4000rpm without a 12v injection pump ;)

then why is it that when someone P Pumps a 24v they just dont put the 12 valve head on as well? i dont thinks its possible for a 12v ported head to outflow a ported out 24v head? as far as a 24v turning 4k rpms, just go buy a redline box and there ya go, 4k rpm beast

inline6power 11-15-2006 07:39 PM

best year for a 12v is a 97 or 98 and best year for a 24v second gen i would go with a 99 or 2000. as far as a common rail motor, the 03 is by far the best you can get.

Forrest Nearing 11-15-2006 08:00 PM


Originally Posted by inline6power (Post 1211072)
then why is it that when someone P Pumps a 24v they just dont put the 12 valve head on as well? i dont thinks its possible for a 12v ported head to outflow a ported out 24v head? as far as a 24v turning 4k rpms, just go buy a redline box and there ya go, 4k rpm beast

you'd have to change to 12v pistons too... ported 12v won't outflow a ported 24v, but it'll come pretty close. valvetrain is WAY cheaper for 12v!!!! ok, you got me on the 4,000rpm... what about 5000rpm? [coffee]

24v's scare me w/ the shared rocker... seen what happens when a valvespring breaks! :(

Common 11-15-2006 08:10 PM

97...

Best year Dodge Cummins PERIOD.

Latest "Old Style" 2nd Gen, so EVERY bug was worked out (minus the KDP) and no chance of a 53 block.

Most hot rodders including the 7 second Cummins dragster use the P7100 which is by far the best injection pump money can buy...

2500 11-15-2006 08:33 PM

kinda biased but seems 97 just before the 53 block issue would be the best. 98.5 12V QC LB without a 53 block could be better.

and yes I've been trying to find a low mileage 98.5 5sp...


Originally Posted by Digital Bullet (Post 1211137)
97...

Best year Dodge Cummins PERIOD.

Latest "Old Style" 2nd Gen, so EVERY bug was worked out (minus the KDP) and no chance of a 53 block.

Most hot rodders including the 7 second Cummins dragster use the P7100 which is by far the best injection pump money can buy...


Common 11-15-2006 09:03 PM


Originally Posted by 2500 (Post 1211191)
kinda biased but seems 97 just before the 53 block issue would be the best. 98.5 12V QC LB without a 53 block could be better.

and yes I've been trying to find a low mileage 98.5 5sp...

All 98.5's were 24v --- good luck!

cumminsdriver635 11-15-2006 10:07 PM


Originally Posted by dodgezilla04 (Post 1210784)
reliability can be sacrificed with too much hotrodding. as with anything.

the newer common rails are easier to build quick, cheap power with. just plug in a downloader or module, and easily 130 hp additional.


As far as reliable, depends on the trans you get and how much you abuse it.

Give me a 12 valve, a grinder,a few simple tools, and a 4k GSK for $130, and about 3 hours. Id say 130hp is no problem on a 12 valve for cheap either:o

But to be honest about it. ANY P7100 12 valve will be about as reliable as you could ever hope for.

Eric

wcbcruzer 11-15-2006 10:09 PM

What bugs did the '96 12v have that the '97 didn't?

dodgezilla04 11-15-2006 10:11 PM

maniac........people with grinders give us modern bombers a bad name[laugh] [laugh]

2500 11-15-2006 10:41 PM

thanks.. should have put to 98.5 12v :D

low mileage 98 12V 5sp LB 4x4 QC non/53 ... hey it could happen[coffee]


Originally Posted by Digital Bullet (Post 1211263)
All 98.5's were 24v --- good luck!


Forrest Nearing 11-15-2006 10:46 PM


Originally Posted by wcbcruzer (Post 1211346)
What bugs did the '96 12v have that the '97 didn't?

a big fat one shaped like a brake booster![dummy] [dummy]


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:17 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands