Water Injection
#32
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Knoxville, TN
Posts: 1,018
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've been looking at this set-up. I just do weekend towing, no sled-pulling or racing.
http://www.alcohol-injection.com/wat...mmins-207.html
Not a bad price, $420.
http://www.alcohol-injection.com/wat...mmins-207.html
Not a bad price, $420.
I'm convinced it's time for me to invest in a water injection kit, but have been going around and around on the possibilites.
So far, the ones I've looked at are:
Painless Coldshot
ATS Waterboy
Coolingmist Stg 3
Snow Performance MPG
Devil's Own
Scheids
Lazarsmith's kit
I may start a new thread on this for more attention, because I'm somewhat at a loss of what to do.
I've searched and read a ton of articles on multipe forums...with no clear direction.
Some say Snow is way overpriced for what you get, and others say it's the only one worth getting. Some say Snow, Coolingmist, and Devils own are starter level mickey mouse kits, and the ATS Waterboy is in a league all of its own. Then some say the ATS Waterboy is a cheap snow knock-off, that only pretends to be a real kit. Then, someone else sold there Coolingmist to get the Waterboy, and said they'd never use the Coolingmist again!
Can someone shed some light on the advantages and/or disadvantages of each kit? I'm not talking vendor bashing, because I'm sure that each kit is useful for the correct application...I'm just not clear on what correct applications are.
I know the Waterboy is a water only kit, and cannot be used with Methanol at all. Other kits (like devils own) can run up to a 50/50, and yet other kits can run full on meth if desired.
Some people say they would never touch methanol because there's too big of a chance to melt pistons, blow headgaskets, etc.
Then others say they wouldn't run anything but a meth/water mix, citing great benefits of chemical cooling, power, increased mileage, etc.
Then, what to do in the winter? It seems that you must either drain and disable the water injection system, or run some meth for freeze protection?
And, then the issue of atomization of the water...my opinion (which includes only reading, and no real life experience) concludes that the devils own nozzles may provide the best atomization. Thoughts? Has anyone "free flowed" there nozzles before installation to observe the atomized discharge?
Then some articles say that water injection is pointless if you still have the grid heaters in place, because the water will condense on the grid elements.
Then, I've read varying opinions on running a conditioner/anti-rust additive...some say not needed, and others say you better not ever run without it?
And, then...the issue of hobbs switch type controllers, or progressive controllers referenced to boost, egt, etc. Is there real efficiency in combustion to be gained by spraying small quantities progressively up to full on? Or is a simple 2 stage hobbs kit for mid range and all out sufficient?
Then, there's people who spray in the intake horn...and then others who say that doing this won't help cylinder 6 at all, and 5 only minimally...that you have to inject into the intake manifold on the head with 6 separate nozzles.
How do you adjust timing to compensate for water? I know that with meth, most people retard the timing some...what about with just water? Are there any hard numbers here?
I've found nozzles are sold in many different flow rates...and I know that you have to sray the right amount of water to correspond with your fueling rate, without quenching combustion. It would seem pretty simple to come up with a table that would give gallon/hour spray of water required for different hp levels (fuel consumption)...has anyone seen this? Any recommendations on what spray is optimal for 600 - 700 hp?
Obviously, I have a lot more questions than answers, but I've tried to read up on everything I can find...either there's not much detailed information out there, or I'm looking in all the wrong spots.
For as little as I know about it, it seems that it may be best to piece a kit together, using the best from each company to cater to your/my specific needs...
Can anyone shed some light here?
#33
I've pretty much decided to go with the new Cooling mist progressive controller on the '07. It will occupy the last spot I have available to install a gauge. The Controller is the only real distinguishing factor. W/M is not all that complicated or ethereal of a modding subject. I wouldn't obsess over it too much. I will buy a custom-sized tank to fit under the toolbox and all the other bits, pump, line, nozzles, valve, etc. piecemeal. I think by shopping around for those other parts I can put it together that way for a little less than a kit and have exactly what I want.
#34
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: McConnellsburg, PA
Posts: 1,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
for lube and rust protection I was told this, or a similar product is what is needed : http://www.kleenflo.com/en/productpages/709.htm
Also I see guys saying they run washer fluid???? Im not interested in running any meth but a friend of mine is and was wondering what to use.
So is there a certain type he needs to use and what else can be used????
#36
Registered User
the inside of the head,valves,stems and seats. If you use water just before shutdown the water can cause the metal inside the head to rust overnight while you sleep. I use one bottle of anti rust from napa per tank. 7 gallons.
#37
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: McConnellsburg, PA
Posts: 1,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#38
That would be very interesting - to know the theory behind how this particular myth got started. Guess I better hurry out to the garage and pull the head to see if my valves are rusted after two years an a hundred gallons of W/M running through my engine without this anti-rust protection.
#39
Registered User
I only "use water" between 17 and 30psi boost. I would be interested to know how anyone could, or why they would "use water" just before shutdown. I suppose maybe if you shut it down at the end of the 1/4 mile before making the turn off the track.
That would be very interesting - to know the theory behind how this particular myth got started. Guess I better hurry out to the garage and pull the head to see if my valves are rusted after two years an a hundred gallons of W/M running through my engine without this anti-rust protection.
That would be very interesting - to know the theory behind how this particular myth got started. Guess I better hurry out to the garage and pull the head to see if my valves are rusted after two years an a hundred gallons of W/M running through my engine without this anti-rust protection.
#41
Registered User
#42
Are you running a sled puller or drag truck that is basically spraying water more or less constantly? If you had rust in the combustion chamber or nearby it was likely because you are spraying too much too soon or you system is not properly set up or malfunctioning in some way. Not because you need an anti-rust additive to the water.
Sounds like your nozzles are too far away from the manifold.
Sounds like your nozzles are too far away from the manifold.
#43
Registered User
Are you running a sled puller or drag truck that is basically spraying water more or less constantly? If you had rust in the combustion chamber or nearby it was likely because you are spraying too much too soon or you system is not properly set up or malfunctioning in some way. Not because you need an anti-rust additive to the water.
#44
I think rust will be the least of your corrosion problems over time regardless of what brew you are putting in there if you keep running it like that.
#45