12 or 20 gauge?
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Place with no quail:(
Posts: 3,337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
12 or 20 gauge?
Well, I am fixing to buy my first shotgun, a Remmington 870 Express...
My mother is VERY anti hunting, so I have never really hunted, last weekend I went out in the field with a good friend of mine that is a very big hunter, we were working his new bird dog and hoping to find Quail... I am now wanting to hunt on a regular basis, and from my understanding of how it works a shotgun would be a great help...
Not sure of the gauge I want, the gun will be used mostly for Quail, other birds, mostly upland, some Ducks and Geese...
Not sure is the lighter 20ga with less recoil would be better, or the wider pattern on a 12ga?
Figured I would post here, as I respect the opinions I get here.
My mother is VERY anti hunting, so I have never really hunted, last weekend I went out in the field with a good friend of mine that is a very big hunter, we were working his new bird dog and hoping to find Quail... I am now wanting to hunt on a regular basis, and from my understanding of how it works a shotgun would be a great help...
Not sure of the gauge I want, the gun will be used mostly for Quail, other birds, mostly upland, some Ducks and Geese...
Not sure is the lighter 20ga with less recoil would be better, or the wider pattern on a 12ga?
Figured I would post here, as I respect the opinions I get here.
#2
Registered User
You want a gun that will cover your spectrum...In my opinion, you need 2 for the hunting you want to do- 12 and 20 ga.
quail and upland, a 20 ga is perfect. For ducks and especially geese, a 12 ga is better.
If you can only afford one gun and plan on hunting all the above like you stated, get a 12 ga. You can get light loads that won't tear up quail and upland birds too bad, and you can also use heavier loads for ducks and geese. Either shotgun has replaceable chokes that will suit your needed pattern for the game you are hunting.
quail and upland, a 20 ga is perfect. For ducks and especially geese, a 12 ga is better.
If you can only afford one gun and plan on hunting all the above like you stated, get a 12 ga. You can get light loads that won't tear up quail and upland birds too bad, and you can also use heavier loads for ducks and geese. Either shotgun has replaceable chokes that will suit your needed pattern for the game you are hunting.
#3
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: U.P. Mi.
Posts: 412
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
12 if your planning on ducks and geese. if your seriouse about geese, need a 3 1/2" chamber too. 870 is an average gun, if you have the money, get something better
#5
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Southern IL
Posts: 685
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm picky, so here goes
Field gun:Upland birds
Any 12, 16, or 20 gauge will do...It's all in what you want to spend
My field gun is a Browning BPS 12GA that was my Dad's...Sentimental more than anything...Only gets used in dry conditions...2-3/4 low brass #6 steel for pheasant
Waterfowl gun:
10 or 12 Gauge...CHEAP PUMP model....Plastic stocks...If 12GA get one thats flexible, I.E.: 2-3/4", 3" and 3-1/2"....Good for anything from September Teal to Giant Canada's in January...CHEAP because this gun's gotta get wet, muddy, dropped in the lake, and in the snow....PUMP cause it's gonna freeze...Pumps are way more reliable in freezing conditions IMHO...Mossberg 835 for me...#4-#2's for ducks, BB-T for geese...3 inchers backed with a candlestick just in case.....
Slugger for deer
Again, any inexpensive gun will do....This is one thats gonna get banged up against the tree, dropped from the tree (hope not-could be deadly)
Like I said, I'm picky, and I dont mix my guns for different uses....No slugs through my bird guns...Field guns dont get wet...Pumps all the way....
So for you, 12GA, either an 870 Express or an 835 will do you fine!!
I live in the "Goose Capital of the World", or so the tourism bureau like to say...Tim Grounds country (even though he's an $##(@%&) Hope you boys up north get LOTS and LOTS of white stuff soon...My dog's getting anxious!!!
Field gun:Upland birds
Any 12, 16, or 20 gauge will do...It's all in what you want to spend
My field gun is a Browning BPS 12GA that was my Dad's...Sentimental more than anything...Only gets used in dry conditions...2-3/4 low brass #6 steel for pheasant
Waterfowl gun:
10 or 12 Gauge...CHEAP PUMP model....Plastic stocks...If 12GA get one thats flexible, I.E.: 2-3/4", 3" and 3-1/2"....Good for anything from September Teal to Giant Canada's in January...CHEAP because this gun's gotta get wet, muddy, dropped in the lake, and in the snow....PUMP cause it's gonna freeze...Pumps are way more reliable in freezing conditions IMHO...Mossberg 835 for me...#4-#2's for ducks, BB-T for geese...3 inchers backed with a candlestick just in case.....
Slugger for deer
Again, any inexpensive gun will do....This is one thats gonna get banged up against the tree, dropped from the tree (hope not-could be deadly)
Like I said, I'm picky, and I dont mix my guns for different uses....No slugs through my bird guns...Field guns dont get wet...Pumps all the way....
So for you, 12GA, either an 870 Express or an 835 will do you fine!!
I live in the "Goose Capital of the World", or so the tourism bureau like to say...Tim Grounds country (even though he's an $##(@%&) Hope you boys up north get LOTS and LOTS of white stuff soon...My dog's getting anxious!!!
#7
Registered User
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Williston, ND
Posts: 1,003
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Marine
As his first shotgun, the 870 will do great. It is one of the best pump guns out there. For what he is using it for, you can't beat it.
Trending Topics
#8
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Place with no quail:(
Posts: 3,337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by texas
hes right and along with a 12gauge you can use it to hunt small birds just use low base trap loads you'll be fine
I anticipate mostly small birds, but wanted a 12 first for the capibaility, even if it mostly shoots lighter loads. But I don't want to destroy every quail and dove I shoot at.
The 870 express is about all I have the cash for at the moment, thus having to pick one now, and comprimise with the gauge. Hopefully by next season I will be able to get a Browning pump in 20ga for upland, and keep the 12ga for waterfowl.
#9
Administrator
I have both a 12 and a 20. My 12 is a Remington 870 Express Magnum. The 20 is made by a company called Noble, its just like the 870, its a pump action.
The 870 is real nice. Depending on the size shot you shoot will determine how hard it will kick. Ex. a slug will kick harder than a load of bird shot.
Trust me, you will like the 870. I love it and it has yet to let me down.
The 870 is real nice. Depending on the size shot you shoot will determine how hard it will kick. Ex. a slug will kick harder than a load of bird shot.
Trust me, you will like the 870. I love it and it has yet to let me down.
#10
Administrator / Scooter Bum
I prefer the 20.........milimeter that is........
Hard to miss with this setup.
And you don't even have to get out of your lawn chair when you see the birds comming.
Hard to miss with this setup.
And you don't even have to get out of your lawn chair when you see the birds comming.
#11
Registered User
Originally Posted by displacedtexan
Thanks, I was pretty much decided on the 12 for versitality.
I anticipate mostly small birds, but wanted a 12 first for the capibaility, even if it mostly shoots lighter loads. But I don't want to destroy every quail and dove I shoot at.
The 870 express is about all I have the cash for at the moment, thus having to pick one now, and comprimise with the gauge. Hopefully by next season I will be able to get a Browning pump in 20ga for upland, and keep the 12ga for waterfowl.
I anticipate mostly small birds, but wanted a 12 first for the capibaility, even if it mostly shoots lighter loads. But I don't want to destroy every quail and dove I shoot at.
The 870 express is about all I have the cash for at the moment, thus having to pick one now, and comprimise with the gauge. Hopefully by next season I will be able to get a Browning pump in 20ga for upland, and keep the 12ga for waterfowl.
#12
Registered User
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Kansas City & Maysville, MO
Posts: 811
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by Shovelhead
I prefer the 20.........milimeter that is........
Hard to miss with this setup.
And you don't even have to get out of your lawn chair when you see the birds comming.
Hard to miss with this setup.
And you don't even have to get out of your lawn chair when you see the birds comming.
#13
Banned
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Cedar Grove, New Jersey
Posts: 3,502
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
get the 12, I got my first 12 at the age of 10, sure if I put a hot round in there it kicked but as I grew I didn't need to upsize, just change loads. Lots of diverse loads available, one for every need but 20 ga on geese? you will send more on to a distant/ unharvested death. I would also highly suggest getting the chamber for 3 1/2 inch loads, never know when you might want to use it and if ya don't have it you are stuck buying something else down the road. Sure I stll have the first 12 but got newer nicer guns because I wanted them, not needed them.
#14
Registered User
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Wyoming
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For your first shotgun the 870 12 Ga is the way to go get use to shooting a shot gun. Just change your chokes and the shot for the game you are going to hunt. Then if you really get into it you can upgrade to a big $$$ gun.
#15
Registered User
Originally Posted by displacedtexan
Well, I am fixing to buy my first shotgun, a Remmington 870 Express...